Study: MySQL use to drop under Oracle ownership

Usage of the open-source MySQL database is set to decline if Oracle succeeds in buying the software's owner, Sun Microsystems, according to new data released by analyst firm The 451 Group on Friday. While 82.1 percent of respondents use MySQL today, that figure will drop to 72.3 percent by 2014, the study found. The firm polled 347 open-source software users.

Fifteen percent said that if Oracle buys Sun, they would be less inclined to use MySQL. Only 6.3 percent indicated they would be more likely to use the database under Oracle's stewardship. Officials there have expressed particular concern over the fate of MySQL under Oracle's ownership. Oracle announced plans to buy Sun in April, but the deal has been held up while European authorities conduct an antitrust review. But some observers have argued that MySQL and Oracle's own database aren't direct competitors, meaning Oracle would have little reason to stifle it. PostgreSQL usage will get a bump as well, growing from 27.1 percent of all users to 30.5 percent by 2014. As for MySQL, some respondents want it to be maintained outside of Oracle. 32.6 percent called for it to be given to an independent organization that would further its development.

In addition, MySQL's code base would live on through offshoot projects like MariaDB. According to the 451 Group study, MariaDB usage is expected to rise from zero today to 3.7 percent of all users by 2014, according to the study. Still, only 4.3 percent said Oracle should be made to sell the database off to another software company. "We do not believe that Oracle would see any of the alternatives to divesting MySQL as any less of a last resort and we do not expect Oracle to offer any concessions," 451 Group analyst Matthew Aslett said in a statement. "However, we believe that Oracle might be more inclined to open up the development of the MySQL database under its own terms in order to encourage more widespread adoption." Meanwhile, Oracle's bid to buy Sun recently received a potential boost from prominent open-source legal expert Eben Moglen, founder and executive director of the Software Freedom Law Center. Moglen issued the opinion after a request from Oracle's legal team, according to a statement. Moglen sent a letter to the European Union on Nov. 19, telling regulators the open-source license used by MySQL, General Public License Version 2, provides adequate protection for parties outside Oracle to develop and redistribute MySQL. "Without expressing any opinion on any other aspect of the Commission's ongoing merger investigation, I believe that the issues raised concerning the GPLv2 status of the MySQL codebase do not warrant a conclusion that this transaction threatens significant anti-competitive consequences," he wrote in part.

EU wants safe volume settings on portable music players

The European Commission has ordered all makers of portable music players to add a default volume setting of around 80 decibels (dB) and a health warning to all new devices within the next two years. The current maximum volume level permitted for portable devices of 100 dB in the European Union remains unchanged, the Commission said in a statement. It is also calling on standards bodies to change industrywide technical safety standards for mobile devices to include the 80 dB default setting. An estimated 10 percent of music player owners in Europe (up to 25 million people) risk going deaf by listening to music at volumes of up to 120 dB - - roughly the volume of a jet airliner taking off - for an hour or more each day on a regular basis, consumer rights commissioner Meglana Kuneva said in a press conference Monday.

Eighty dB is roughly the volume of road traffic."It's easy to push up the volume on your MP3 player to damagingly loud levels, especially on busy streets or public transport," Kuneva said, adding that young people especially "have no idea they can be putting their hearing at risk."The new standard default setting on devices won't prevent users from overriding the default settings and pumping up the volume, but there will be clear warnings so they know the risks they are taking, Kuneva said. You can safely listen to music at 80 dB for up to 40 hours a week without harming your ears, a study conducted for the Commission concluded. The industry said it supported the move but it warned the Commission not to try to prescribe universal volume levels for all users. Bridget Cosgrave, director general of the trade group Digital Europe, added that music players are only one part of the problem of hearing loss, but the industry would cooperate in the European initiative, "to best serve consumer interests" she said. It urged the Commission and standardization bodies to match the wishes of users with safety considerations when they set the default level. Digital Europe called for global harmonization of the standards to be applied in Europe. "Unharmonised requirements would undermine credibility and confuse users, potentially exposing themselves to inappropriate volume of noise," the trade group said in a statement.

Kuneva warned firms that she won't tolerate their failure to observe the new standards. "Regardless how big the company, no matter how reputable, I will take action," the commissioner said. And it warned the Commission against setting "overly stringent regulations", pointing out that this would drive sales of products to countries with more relaxed regulation.

Lawsuits over Heartland data breach folded into one

A lawsuit consolidating 16 separate class-action complaints brought by financial institutions against Heartland Payment Systems Inc. has been filed in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas. The complaints allege that the payment processor was negligent in its duty to protect card holder data. The claims stem from the massive data breach disclosed by Princeton, N.J.-based Heartland in January.

The amended complaint includes for the first time several statements that Heartland is alleged to have made regarding the controls it had in place to protect credit and debit card data just prior to the breach. The lawsuit seeks compensation from Heartland for the costs that the financial institutions say they've had to bear in notifying customers about the breach and in reissuing new payment cards. The fact that the company suffered the breach despite its claimed security measures shows that Heartland either negligently or deliberately misrepresented the facts, the lawsuit alleged. Among the financial institutions listed are the Pennsylvania State Employees Credit Union, Lone Star Bank of North America and Amalgamated Bank of New York. "There were multiple lawsuits filed all over the country on behalf of financial institutions, and all of those cases were sent to federal court in Houston" for consolidation, said Joseph Sauder, an attorney with Chimicles & Tikellis LLP. The Haverford, Penn.-based law firm is representing some of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit. "This complaint incorporates the strongest claims from all of the financial institution class-action lawsuits," Sauder said. "The next step is for Heartland to file a response to this complaint," he said. The breach, which is considered the biggest involving payment card data, compromised more than 100 million credit and debit cards.

Heartland on Jan. 20 disclosed that unknown intruders had broken into its network sometime last year and accessed payment card data belonging to an undisclosed number of customers. So far, Heartland has publicly admitted to spending nearly $13 million on breach-related costs, and analysts expect it will cost the company millions more in the coming years. The cases were consolidated in federal court in Texas because Heartland's data centers are located in that state, Sauder said. Heartland, one of the biggest payment processors in the U.S., manages about 100 million credit and debit-card transactions per month. A "separate track" of cases involving consumer lawsuits against Heartland is also being heard in the same court, Sauder said. BJ's Wholesale Club, Hannaford Bros. and Dave & Buster's restaurant chain.

In September, Albert Gonzalez, 28, of Miami pleaded guilty to the data heist at Heartland and several other retailers, including TJX Companies Inc. Gonzalez is scheduled to be sentenced in December and faces 15 to 20 years in prison under the terms of his plea agreement. Heartland did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

DOJ requires AT&T to sell some assets in acquisition

The U.S. Department of Justice will require telecom giant AT&T to sell off pieces of its mobile network in parts of Louisiana and Mississippi in order to continue with its US$944 million acquisition of Centennial Communications, the agency said Tuesday. The area covered includes parts of southwestern and central Louisiana and southwestern Mississippi. If AT&T did not divest its assets in the two states, the acquisition would "substantially lessen" competition for mobile telecom services and would likely result in higher prices, lower quality and reduced network investments, the DOJ said.

The DOJ's Antitrust Division, along with the attorney general of Louisiana, filed a civil lawsuit Tuesday in U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia to block the proposed acquisition of Centennial by AT&T. At the same time, the DOJ and the Louisiana attorney general filed a proposed settlement that, if approved by the court, would resolve the competitive concerns in the lawsuit. The complaint alleges that the proposed transaction would substantially reduce competition for mobile wireless telecommunications services in each of the areas. According to the complaint, AT&T and Centennial are each other's closest competitors for a significant number of customers in eight cellular marketing areas (CMAs), as defined by the U.S. Federal Communications Commission. AT&T is the second-largest mobile telecom provider in the U.S. by number of subscribers, serving nearly 80 million subscribers throughout all 50 states, the DOJ said. Centennial is the eighth-largest mobile telecom provider in the U.S., with about 1.1 million subscribers in six states, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands. In 2008, AT&T earned mobile revenues of about $44 billion.

Dell details the Efficient Enterprise strategy at OpenWorld

Dell Chairman and CEO Michael Dell touted Dell's "Efficient Enterprise" strategy Wednesday at the Oracle OpenWorld 2009 conference and was joined briefly onstage by Oracle CEO Larry Ellison, who stressed that Oracle is a major user of Dell equipment as well as a partner. Standardization involves use of Intel processors, Dell explained. Dell's strategy centers on standardization, simplification, and automation.

Simplification entails making the complex simple using solutions like virtualization and storage consolidation, while automation is about streamlining service delivery and enabling self-service IT models, Dell said during a keynote presentation at the San Francisco conference. [ Also at OpenWorld, Ellison and Sun Chairman Scott McNealy lauded Sun technologies. ] He cited figures stating that of the $1.2 trillion spent annually on IT infrastructure, nearly $800 billion is spent on labor and services, while just $400 billion goes to hardware and related software. Dell stressed Intel as the industry standard. "The numbers really don't lie. [Intel] x86 is the standard architecture in the datacenter," he said. Meanwhile, just 1 percent of total business spending is left for driving IT innovation, Dell said. "We believe there's a real opportunity to drive out inefficiency and make technology work harder for our customers, and it forms the basis of what we call the Efficient Enterprise "Dell said.  He vowed that Dell would reduce $200 billion of inefficiency out of the $1.2 trillion. Dell referred to Intel versus "proprietary architectures" in promoting Intel-based systems. Our partnership just gets bigger and bigger every year," Ellison said.

Ellison briefly joined Dell to stress Oracle and Dell synergies. "We've got so many customers that are Dell customers and also Oracle customers. Oracle also is a major Dell user, with 20,000 Dell servers that Oracle uses to run its development and testing operations, Ellison said. Ellison did not address what could be a sticky predicament in that Oracle soon will own the rival Sun Microsystems hardware line if a proposed $7.4 billion merger goes through as planned. Dell technology is "working well for us," he said. Sun hardware is largely based on the SPARC CPU platform, with some Intel-based machines in the mix. Virtual machines, Dell said, are becoming key to driving workloads form the client to the cloud.

Efficient Enterprise, Dell said, is intended to enable greater spending on innovation and less on maintenance.  Enterprise efficiency also is about giving IT administrators increased visibility into deployed workloads, Dell said. Dell is driving its "virtual-ready infrastructure," he said.  The company is delivering automation and flexibility and self-service IT through cloud computing, said Dell. This story, "Dell details the Efficient Enterprise stretegy at OpenWorld," was originally published at InfoWorld.com. He cited 7-11 as one enterprise that has moved to Dell's managed services to improve service delivery. Follow the latest developments in open source at InfoWorld.com.

FCC net neutrality proposal is 'dramatic shift' in policy

U.S. Federal Communications Commission Chairman Julius Genachowski's decision to seek to formalize net neutrality rules would either bring "unconstitutional" new regulations to the Internet or a welcome "paradigm shift" in U.S. communications policy, depending on whom you talk to. Genachowski also pushed to apply the net neutrality regulations to mobile broadband providers, and he called for an expansion in existing broadband policy principles to prohibit broadband providers from discriminating against Web content and services while allowing them to engage in reasonable network management. Genachowski announced Monday that he will ask his fellow commissioners to support a rulemaking proceeding to create formal net neutrality rules that would prohibit Internet providers from selectively blocking or slowing Web content and applications.

The FCC has been enforcing net neutrality principles on a case-by-case basis since August 2005, but formal rules would ensure that application and content developers on the "edge" of broadband networks can innovate without interference from network operators, Genachowski said in a speech at the Brookings Institution. "This is the power of the Internet: distributed innovation and ubiquitous entrepreneurship, the potential for jobs and opportunity everywhere there is broadband," he said. "Saying nothing - and doing nothing - would impose its own form of unacceptable cost. It would deny the benefits of predictable rules of the road to all players in the Internet ecosystem." But some broadband providers and conservative think tanks suggested Genachowski's plan could lead to burdensome new regulations. It would deprive innovators and investors of confidence that the free and open Internet we depend on today will still be here tomorrow. The FCC is currently developing a national broadband plan and Genachowski's proposal might "change the rules of the road" before that's completed, said Ken Ferree, president of the Progress and Freedom Foundation, a conservative think tank. "I'm troubled to learn that the FCC is embarking on an exercise that would probably result in rules that are unconstitutional and almost certainly beyond the FCC's statutory jurisdiction," he said in an e-mail. "Aside from the legal issues it raises though, I find myself at a loss to understand why the administration wants to start meddling with a sector of the economy that, despite a challenging macro-economic environment, is performing pretty well by any rational standard. The FCC used its broadband policy principles to prohibit Comcast from blocking or slowing peer-to-peer traffic in a commission vote in August 2008. Comcast was glad to see that Genachowski appeared to suggest that the Internet is now free and open, Comcast Executive Vice President David Cohen said in a blog post. "Before we rush into a new regulatory environment for the Internet, let's remember there can be no doubt that the Internet has enjoyed immense growth even as these debates have gone on," he wrote. "The Internet in America has been a phenomenal success that has spawned technological and business innovation unmatched anywhere in the world. It's almost as if they are trying to turn a story of success into one of failure." Broadband provider Comcast said it welcomes a dialogue about net neutrality, but officials there questioned if more regulations are needed.

So it's still fair to ask whether increased regulation of the Internet is a solution in search of a problem." CTIA, a trade group representing mobile carriers, said it was concerned that the FCC could make rules that prohibit mobile carriers from differentiating their products and services. The Internet is a work in progress, and we really don't know what it's going to look like five years from now," he said. "We believe that new capabilities will be created by innovation in the network, and those new capabilities and innovation should not be precluded by regulation." Young said he was glad to hear Genachowski say the end result of the rulemaking has not been determined in advance. "We need to determine what are the problems that need to be fixed," he said. "What are the examples that require a dramatic change in the regulatory policy of dealing with the Internet." Until now, U.S. lawmakers and regulators have had a hands-off approach to the Internet, Young added. Genachowski pointed to limited competition among service providers as part of the need for new net neutrality rules, but competition is strong among mobile carriers, said Chris Guttman-McCabe, vice president of regulatory affairs at CTIA. "We are concerned about the unintended consequences Internet regulation would have on consumers considering that competition within the industry has spurred innovation, investment, and growth for the U.S. economy," Guttman-McCabe said in a statement. "Unlike the other platforms that would be subject to the rules, the wireless industry is extremely competitive, extremely innovative, and extremely personal." Verizon Communications supports a free and open Internet, but new FCC rules could make it difficult for broadband providers to offer security features or other innovative products, said David Young, the company's vice president for federal regulatory affairs. But Genachowski and Gigi Sohn, president of digital rights group Public Knowledge, said net neutrality rules wouldn't really be new. Over the past four years, there's been a heated debate in Washington, D.C., about the need for net neutrality rules, he said. "It is the elixir of consumer choice and competition that we have long been waiting to see firmly applied in the Internet space," Scott said. "We're going to settle this question once and for all, and we're going to deliver an open Internet for the U.S." Other companies and groups supporting Genachowski's announcement included Google, Skype, the Consumer Electronics Association, and the Computer and Communications Industry Association, a tech trade group.

Until 2005, when the FCC changed the rules, broadband providers had to operate open networks to share with competitors, Sohn said. "American Internet users should be celebrating today," Sohn said. "After four years of regulatory uncertainty, the FCC chairman announced that the agency will start a proceeding to adopt rules that will ensure an open Internet on every single broadband platform." Ben Scott, policy director at media reform group Free Press, called Genachowski's announcement a "paradigm shift" in FCC policy that will ensure the health of the Internet. Senator Byron Dorgan, a North Dakota Democrat, also welcomed Genachowski's plan. This principle of open access has been the cornerstone of the Internet's growth so far, and is vital to its continued success in the future." Dorgan has pushed for net neutrality legislation in the U.S. Congress. "An open and democratic Internet is necessary in order to allow innovation, economic opportunities, and consumer benefits to flourish, and it is critical that we maintain this access," Dorgan said in a statement. "By ensuring that consumers and online businesses can use the Internet without interference from broadband service providers, net neutrality will prevent the advent of haves and have-nots.

Benioff plays nice to Oracle at OpenWorld

Attendees packed into a presentation by Salesforce.com Chairman and CEO Marc Benioff at Oracle's OpenWorld conference Tuesday, but those hoping the executive would deliver some of his trademark trash talk toward Oracle left the room disappointed. But Benioff made no response to Ellison's jibes on Tuesday, instead referring to the companies' "fantastic relationship" and thanking Oracle for being "magnanimous" enough to let Salesforce.com appear at OpenWorld. Some sort of throwdown seemed possible, even likely, given that during a shareholder meeting last week, Oracle CEO Larry Ellison mocked Salesforce.com's offering as a "little itty-bitty application" that is dependent on Oracle's own technology.

Salesforce.com is a sponsor of the show. Since then, the two executives have repeatedly slammed each other's business model, with Benioff declaring on-premise software a dying model and Ellison famously mocking cloud computing on a number of occasions, even as his own company tests those waters. Ellison was an early investor in Salesforce.com, but left the vendor's board after he and Benioff had a falling out. Their history caused surprise and curiosity among some observers, who questioned why Oracle would allow such a direct rival to tout its products at OpenWorld. And during the shareholder meeting, Ellison said he could provide a long list of customers who once used Salesforce.com but "chucked it out" in favor of Oracle's own on-demand CRM (customer relationship management) software.

Indeed, beyond slamming Salesforce.com's technological achievements, Ellison has made it a point during recent earnings conference calls to cite deals it won against the on-demand vendor. But in the end, Benioff seemed more intent Tuesday on building bridges than burning them. The two companies announced a partnership on Monday for selling Salesforce.com CRM and related services to small and medium-sized businesses. At one point, he was joined onstage by Dell CEO Michael Dell. Salesforce.com and Dell already had close ties, having used each other's products for some time. Dell said its experience running Salesforce.com will give it an edge when working with new customers.